Tuesday, May 5, 2009

How Do You Do? I'm Sorry For Your Loss

The words we say when trying to comfort others can often be misunderstood or over-analyzed.
When I was in kindergarten, my friend Alex was knocked over, along with his block tower, by another student who was haplessly running through the area.  When I felt bad or was hurt, my parents often said 'I'm sorry', and that was what I said to Alex when he got up crying.  Alex wasn't comforted by my words though, instead he sounded surprised and angry.  "You didn't do it!  What are you sorry about?"


This is not just a child's reaction.  In mortuary school, another fellow student and apprentice funeral director had been out to some one's home after a death.  He told the widow that he was sorry about her husband, and her response was quite similar to Alex's, "What are you sorry about?  You didn't even know him!" She was angry and felt that his comment was not genuine; just another line handed out to everyone without thought or sincerity.  
Just as I didn't know how to respond to Alex, the apprentice didn't know what to say back to the widow, other than that he was sorry, and that hadn't worked very well the first time. 

Unfortunately, the apprentice vowed that he wouldn't ever say he was sorry to a grieving person again.  I hope that by now, he has changed his mind, because I know that what he was really trying to communicate was that as just another person, whether he knew the deceased or the family or not, he was sorry that such a sad thing had happened to her.  Surely humans have not grown so callous that they cannot feel for strangers in their grief.  In saying "I'm sorry for your loss" or 'I'm sorry about your mom" we are expressing our sadness about the situation and it's effect on another person, not pity or guilt, and not a claim that we know the depth or the unique personal feelings involved in this loss. 
 


In a language filled with expressions that are not always meant literally; in which 'How do you do?' is not a question at all, but means 'Nice to meet you'; and the response is 'How do you do?' again, meaning 'Nice to meet you too', perhaps 'I'm sorry for your loss' may be the closest our words can approach the meaning that underlies them.
There will always be anger and misunderstandings where language is concerned, but I believe that when delivered with the correct tone, even a statement like 'How are you' will be understood by a hurting person to be an expression of caring and interest, and not the unthinking blunder that it otherwise could be taken for.
We need to continually be conscious and careful about the words we use with the grieving, but we should never stop telling them that we are sorry, that we care, and that we feel for them in their loss. 

6 comments:

Charles Cowling said...

The problem with words is that they cannot be unsaid. We all know how horrible that can sometimes feel!

I guess it has a lot to do with timing. Wait for the appropriate moment. If you are going to express sympathy, allow time for the other person to become aware of your fellow-feeling sympathy. Then your words will come across as sincere, not merely conventional.

And yet, as we know, we can always be damned if we do and damned if we don't!

Charles Cowling said...

Here's an interesting link:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vPh8GbKgOJc

Ru Callender said...

Patrick,
Thank you this post.
Saying I'm sorry can make you feel impotent, and open you up to a blast of anger, but it's all we have, and to stop saying it is to lose a little piece of ourselves.
I really enjoy your blog. It's wise and gentle and ecletic and interested. Thank you

Monika said...

Maybe the sensitivity is a response to a stand-alone "I'm sorry." I've experienced that jarring effect, even when it came from the well intended. For me, the most heartfelt condolence comes when something short and genuine is added to the generic, "I'm so sorry for your loss." "Your Dad was a great guy." "Your Mom's smile always lit up a room." Even, "I can't imagine what you're going through..." was strangely helpful.

Patrick McNally said...

Thank you, that's a very good point, Monika, and should have been mentioned here. For more things that are helpful to say, please visit my December post on What to Say to the Grieving http://www.dailyundertaker.com/2008/12/what-to-say-to-grieving.html

Joanthan Taylor said...

When I began working as a bereavement support volunteer, I discovered it's not just a myth - people actually do cross the street to avoid having to talk to the bereaved. It makes them feel contagious, isolated and all the more bereft.

So now, I make a point of crossing the street to talk to someone if I know they've lost a precious human being, even if it's to say 'how useless words are to say this, but I'm glad I saw you.'

Related Posts with Thumbnails

Contact Me

My Photo
Funeral service faces a crisis of relevance, and I am passionate about keeping the best traditions of service alive while adapting to the changing needs of families. Feel free to contact me with questions, or to share your thoughts on funeral service, ritual, and memorialization. dailyundertaker@gmail.com

Followers